Trattoria 35

Stepping into Trattoria 35 feels like entering a cherished neighborhood retreat where genuine warmth and quiet refinement mingle effortlessly. Nestled in the heart of Bayside, this Italian restaurant welcomes you with an inviting glow and a comfortable rhythm that encourages you to settle in and savor the moment. Whether it’s a family gathering, an intimate dinner, or a spontaneous outing with friends, the pace here is unhurried, the atmosphere approachable yet attentive, and the space thoughtfully arranged to foster connection without rush.

From the moment you’re greeted by the front-of-house team, there’s a sense of being valued not just as a customer but as part of a shared experience. The subtly elegant interior balances classic Italian charm with a lively but relaxed spirit, where candlelight softens the evening and the quiet hum of conversation feels like familiar background music. Attentive service flows naturally around the room, creating a space where your needs are anticipated rather than requested, adding ease to your time at the table.

The culinary journey here gently unfolds through dishes that honor tradition while embracing a certain warmth and homeliness. You can feel the care in the simple pleasures — from the crispness of a well-tossed spinach salad to the richness found in a creamy fettucine alfredo or the savory charm of skirt steak pizzaiola. Seasonal touches and thoughtful details come alive in specialties like grilled octopus or shrimp oreganata, paired seamlessly with a glass of red wine or a freshly made lemon drop martini that adds a bright note to the evening.

What resonates most is how the food and service blend to create memorable human moments — a shared plate of charcuterie, laughter exchanged over a classic margherita pie, the comforting familiarity of rigatoni alla Michael, or the indulgence of a velvety chocolate mousse cake to close the night. There’s a feeling here that you’re returning to a place that’s known you for years, even if it’s your first time through the door.

Trattoria 35 holds its place as a steady, beloved corner of Bayside’s dining scene—where longtime patrons and new visitors alike can find a comfortable seat, a thoughtful meal, and the kind of warmth that only comes from places rooted in genuine care and community.